Guest Stars Jean Smart as Arlane Hart Kevin Zegers as Toby Joe Tippett as Bobby Sellars Katrina Bowden as Cindi Eddie Kehler as Detective Rob Mooney Steven Walters as Bobby's Lawyer Co Starring Ethan Jones as Young Toby Garikayi Mutambirwa as Officer Stewart David Stanbra as Officer O'Hara Maggie Contreras as Karen Kate Lin as Megan