Guest Stars Jean Smart as Arlane Hart Keiko Agena as Nancy Kevin Zegers as Toby Jeff Perry as Mike O'Neil Joelle Carter as Denise Meehan-Shepard Michelle Arthur as TBD Brent Anderson as Detective Marco Layton Adam Harrington as Matt Murphy Tommy Savas as Max Rebecca Lowman as Detective Roberts Casimere Jollette as Skylar Co Starring Alison Robertson as Woman #1 Olga Aguilar as Woman #2 Quinn Sullivan as Jamie Eddie Aguirre as Irvine Uniform #2 Christopher Goffard as Himself Patty Tobin as Irvine Uniform