Guest Stars Melanie Merkosky as Carla Co Starring Jovanna Burke as Bloody Mary / Mary Worthington Isabella Barr as Carla's Daughter Madison Barr as Carla's Daughter Shanae Tomasevich as Woman in White Jasmine Miriguay as Rachel Amanda Spinosa as Rachel's Friend Sean Tyson as Clown Ghost / John Wayne Gacy Peter Skagen as Sheriff Kyle Strauts as Cadaverous Ghost