Guest Stars William Windom as Dr. Seth Hazlitt Ron Masak as Sheriff Mort Metzger Julie Adams as Eve Simpson Richard Paul as Mayor Sam Booth Ruth Roman as Loretta Speigel Gloria DeHaven as Phyllis Grant Sally Klein as Corrine Kathryn Grayson as Ideal Molloy Orson Bean as Ebeneezer McEnery Holland Taylor as Winifred Thayer Phyllis Franklin as Mabel William Lanteau as Howard John Considine as Horton Thayer Basil Hoffman as Milton Overguard Lee Purcell as Annie May Chapman Barbara Perry as Party Guest Courtenay McWhinney as 1st Lady Sheila Pinkham as 2nd Lady Charles Woolf as Fulton