Guest Stars Matilda Szydagis as Zelda Joel Johnstone as Archie Cleary Brian Tarantina as Jackie Justine Lupe as Astrid Weissman Emily Bergl as Tessie Zachary Levi as Benjamin Ettenberg Jason Alexander as Asher Friedman Cary Elwes as Gavin Hawk Veanne Cox as Corinne Michael Countryman as Simon Michael Arden as Milken Prince Lucy DeVito as Irene Joey Slotnick as Dickie Trent Dawson as Scott Will Rogers as Johnny Co Starring Nunzio Pascale as Ethan Matteo Pascale as Ethan Teddy Coluca as Manny Jack O'Connell as Jerry Connor Ratliff as Chester Victor Verhaeghe as Antonio Chris Chirdon as Don Logan Riley Bruner as Lance Lauren Norvelle as Moira Brandon Salerno as Truman Bern Cohen as Rabbi Krinsky Connor Russell as Abbie Stephen Badalamenti as Junior Adam Grupper as David Rosenbaum Erin Neufer as Darla Adam Griffin as Roy Leslie Shenkel as Levi Susan Jeffries as Woman in Tiara Alix Elias as Susie's Mom Alison Cimmet as Joan Ben Warheit as Nicholas Jenny Sterlin as Edna Drummond Gregory Abbey as Pat Jeff Brooks as Pete Drummond Erin Fritch as Apartment Mom Mark Jacoby as Professor Lerman Susan Pellegrino as Maureen Nat DeWolf as Thomason