Guest Stars Drew Tanner as Fangs Fogarty Nathalie Boltt as Penelope Blossom Molly Ringwald as Mary Andrews Shannon Purser as Ethel Muggs Trinity Likins as Jellybean Jones Wyatt Nash as Charles Smith Kerr Smith as Principal Holden Honey Kett Turton as David Billy Wickman as Hunter Malloy Spencer Lord as Terry Steve Makaj as Jinx Malloy Co Starring Marion Eisman as Doris Bell Hannah Bos as Young Betty Austin Miklautsch as Darius Joshua Guvi as Daryl Lexi Hill as Audrey Fritzy-Klevans Destine as Bulldog #1 Brock Brown as Young Archie Don Ainsworth as Jimmy Daniel Schoepf as Ray Malloy Dawson Rutledge as Frat Boy #1 Noam Zyblerman as Paul Malloy