Guest Stars Sarah Gilman as Penny Gill Melissa Saint-Amand as Lucia Marshman Katie Stevens as Lindsey Willows Michael Trotter as Justin Einsteen Shelley Robertson as CPS Officer Mary Phlippen Jonathan R. Freeman as Edward Allen Co Starring Carol Hoyt as Mrs. Geice Wil J. Jackson as Lead Officer Samuel Davis as Medic Joseph Callari as Mr. Geice Kimberlee Kidd as Darcy Marshman Walker Barnes as Teenager