Special Guest Stars Shantel VanSanten as Special Agent Nina Chase Guest Stars Taylor Anthony Miller as Kelly Moran Vedette Lim as Elise Taylor Thomas Philip O'Neill as M.E. Dr. Neil Mosbach Amelia Workman as BAU Psychologist Erin Leigh Peck as Mrs. Logan Woody Fu as Doctor Chin Benny Mora as Derek Lawson Ian Stuart as Frank Silver Co Starring Tracey Conyer Lee as NYPD Detective Claudia Ross Erika Woods as Nurse #2 Rob Barnes as Judge Draper Reggie A. Green as Elliott Washburn Joseph Tudisco as Vendor Meltem Gulturk as Nurse #1 Douglas Everett Davis as Doctor Paul Hendrix Andrea Figliomeni as Mary Fuller Jeremy Morse as Father Roger Burns