Guest Stars Curtis Armstrong as Metatron Samantha Isler as Young Amara Co Starring Yasmeene Ball as Teenage Amara Jesse Reid as Minion #2 / Jarvis Claude Knowlton as Detective Madsen Dan Willows as Demon Minion Eva Day as Goldie Schmidtlapp Dani Alvarado as Rene Watkins Grace Vukovic as Goldie's Friend Tommy Douglas as Dying Man Araz Yaghoubi as Demon Aide Mike Gazzola as Marco Luke Jennings as Delivery Man Warren Abbott as Cop