Guest Stars Michael Muhney as Sheriff Don Lamb Erica Gimpel as Alicia Fennel Jeffrey D. Sams as Terrence Cook Cress Williams as Nathan Woods Dana Davis as Cora Briggs Claire Titelman as Mandy Christine Estabrook as Madame Sophie Co Starring Brandon Hillock as Deputy Jerry Sacks Linda Castro as Mrs. Murphy Jonathan Chesner as Corny Martin Yu as Mr. Wu Melissa Renée Martin as Mean Girl Lee Ann Kim as Moderator Justin Foley as Pizza Guy Molly Lorenne as Fader #3 Cherisse Osei as Fader #2 Toy Valentine as Fader #1 Samantha Klein as Michele