Guest Stars Frank McGrath as Charlie Wooster Terry Wilson as Bill Hawks Patty McCormack as Mary Ellen Thomas Vernon Rich as Jenkins Ken Osmond as Tommy Jenkins Mario Gallo as Chief Red Cloud Maria Gallo as Chief Red Cloud Jenny Hecht as Sally Mayhew Richard H. Cutting as Ben Mayhew Barbara Pepper as Mrs. Maybelle Gifford Clifford Botelho as Indian Boy Ollie O'Toole as Stacy Gifford Claudia Bryar as Mrs. Mayhew Uncredited Chick Hannan as Regular Wagon Train Member Lillian O'Malley as Regular Wagon Train Member Bill Clark as Wagon Train Member Al Haskell as Wagon Train Member