Guest Stars Frank McGrath as Charlie Wooster Terry Wilson as Bill Hawks Orville Sherman as Freehan Robert Brown as Tim O'Toole Jan Arvan as Indian Chief Quintin Sondergaard as Soldier Kathleen O'Malley as Sharry O'Toole Neyle Morrow as Cheyenne Indian Gina Gillespie as Peggy O'Toole Terence de Marney as Mike O'Toole Charles Laughton as Colonel Albert Farnsworth James Fairfax as Jeremy Oakes John Kroger as Lieutenant Credit Only Robert Horton as Flint McCullough Uncredited Chick Hannan as Regular Wagon Train Member Rod McGaughy as Soldier