Guest Stars Frank McGrath as Charlie Wooster Terry Wilson as Bill Hawks Susan Oliver as Cathy Eckhart Martin Landau as Preacher Vivi Janiss as Sarah Harness Gregory Walcott as Jefferson Miller John Larch as Ben Harness Ron Hayes as Whitey Brad Johnson as Lieutenant Credit Only Robert Horton as Flint McCullough Uncredited Chick Hannan as Regular Wagon Train Member Art Felix as Wagon Train Member Fox O'Callahan as Wagon Train Member Claire Carleton as Woman