Special Guest Stars Rip Torn as Don Geiss Guest Stars Marceline Hugot as Kathy Geiss Diane Neal as Erin Robyn Lively as Kelsey Steve Witting as Rob Janel Moloney as Jessica Jason Kravits as Keith Susan Barrett as Diane Co Starring Laura Hunter Drago as Young Erin Marion McCorry as The Woman Jeff Hiller as Hotel Clerk Rik Alan Walter as Man Gerrianne Raphael as The Nun Katy Grenfell as Passerby Nicole Patrick as Young Kelsey Gabe Hernandez as Bartender Uncredited Adam Smith Jr. as Prop Master Yaron Urbas as High School Classmate