Guest Stars Chris Noth as Mr. Big Carrie Preston as Madeline Dunn Stephen Barker Turner as Jeremy Co Starring John Mese as Dave David Beach as Bandleader Mike Dooly as Martin Kevin Hagan as Mr. Healy Grace Naughton as Busy Female Executive Buzz Bovshow as Man Mary Jane Wells as Mrs. Healy Paul Haber as Cute Investment Banker David McCann as Doorman