Guest Stars Joe Morton as Eli Pope Brian Letscher as Tom Larsen Dan Bucatinsky as James Novak Eben Ham as Tanner Shaw Vanya Asher as Ethan Dinora Walcott as Reporter Carol Stoney Westmoreland as Hal Rimbeau Lisa Kudrow as Congresswoman Josephine Marcus Keith Sellon-Wright as Garrett Cole Patrick St. Esprit as Peter Foster Wayne Alexander as TV Reporter Patrick Fabian as Senator Richard Meyers Melora Hardin as Shelley Meyers Angela E. Gibbs as Judge Eleanor Gaynes Kimrie Lewis as Legal Reporter Michael B. Silver as Gavin Mitchell Angelique Cinelu as Mariah Peters Adam Burch as 1st Reporter David Douglas as Anchor 1 Cindy Drummond as Marion Peter Asle Holden as William Granville Darius De La Cruz as Court Clerk Elizabeth Stocks as News Reporter Heather Fogarty as Hayley Liz Gonzalez as Kelly Roy Vongtama as Anchor 2 Shuko Akune as Congresswoman Samantha Dandridge Ashley Dulaney as Ashley Thomas Crawford as Desiree's Father Taylor Treadwell as Reporter Nichelle Hines as Anchor 3