Guest Stars Joe Morton as Eli Pope George Newbern as Charlie Kate Burton as Sally Langston Brian Letscher as Tom Larsen Dan Bucatinsky as James Novak Paul Adelstein as Leo Bergen Jon Tenney as Vice President Andrew Nichols Tom Amandes as Governor Samuel Reston Greta Jung as Producer Jennifer Peo as Vanessa Chandler Lauren Stamile as Carla Julia Cho as Shelby Moss Brent Briscoe as Reverend