Guest Stars Joe Morton as Eli Pope George Newbern as Charlie Portia de Rossi as Elizabeth North Eben Ham as Tanner Shaw Vanya Asher as Ethan Matthew Del Negro as Michael Ambruso Steven W. Bailey as Noah Elliot Tim Ransom as Jeremy Winslow Stefanie Black as Holly Sonya Walger as Katherine Winslow Kyle Secor as Dale Nick Hoffa as Jeff Asperton Andrew Thacher as Mystery Man Ron Perkins as Judge Henry Sparks Wilke Itzin as Wes Uncredited Chris Sundlee as Court Observer