Special Guest Stars Chris Noth as Peter Florrick America Ferrera as Natalie Flores Guest Stars Chris Butler as Matan Brody Sarah Steele as Marissa Gold Scott Porter as Blake Calamar Gaby Hoffmann as Rhonda Cerone Sam Robards as Jarvis Bowes Baylen Thomas as Sheriff Gavin Lee as Jake Alister Robert Petkoff as Dr. Ben Truestall Roxanna Hope Radja as Babette Penn Co Starring Rebecca Brooksher as Lana Timmerman Leslie Lyles as Judge Jane Moretti James DeMarse as Judge Alan Breen Dennis Flanagan as Officer Deitch Jennifer Lim as Will's Aide Jamie Tirelli as Luis Flores