Guest Stars S. John Launer as Judge Peggy Maley as Edna Freeman Lewis Charles as Sidney Otis Max Showalter as Carl Reynolds Tommy Cook as Frank Lane Dorothy Neumann as Ellen Crandall James Seay as Dr. Michael Harris Christine White as Rhoda Reynolds John Hoyt as Philip Reynolds Michael Emmet as Arthur "Artie" Kane James Nolan as Deputy Uncredited Lee Miller as Sgt. Brice Frank Mills as Courtroom Spectator Edwin Rochelle as Courtroom Spectator Jack Stoney as Juror Don Anderson as Courtroom Spectator Sid Tomack as Courtroom Spectator