Special Guest Stars Rick Springfield as Lucifer Guest Stars Samantha Smith as Mary Winchester Ruth Connell as Rowena MacLeod Woody Jeffreys as Tommy Co Starring Nikolai Witschl as Coroner Gwenda Lorenzetti as Cheryl Kellinger Aadila Dosani as Natalia Christian Convery as Lucas Kellinger Nevis Unipan as Girl Ghost Cameron Grierson as Hugo Moriarty Nancy Kerr as Wendy Kyle Warren as Dave Bracken Hanke as Girl Ghost