Guest Stars Samantha Smith as Mary Winchester Kim Rhodes as Sheriff Jody Mills Lisa Berry as Billie Kara Royster as Alicia Banes Kendrick Sampson as Max Banes Billy Wickman as Elvis Katz Mac Brandt as Bucky Sims Laurie Paton as Lorraine Fox Co Starring Shaine Jones as Asa Fox Jack Moore as Young Asa Fox Darren E. Scott as Randy Bull Maddy Lawson as Date #1 Amelia Crossley as Date #2 Julia Mack as Date #3
