Recurring Guest Characters Dr. Seth Hazlitt 42 guest appearances Sheriff Mort Metzger 29 guest appearances Sheriff Amos Tupper 19 guest appearances Deputy Andy Broom 13 guest appearances Grady Fletcher 12 guest appearances Eve Simpson 9 guest appearances Michael Hagarty 7 guest appearances Deputy Floyd 7 guest appearances NYPD Lieutenant Artie Gelber 6 guest appearances Dennis Stanton 6 guest appearances Charlie Garrett 5 guest appearances Captain Ethan Cragg 4 guest appearances Harlan "Harry" A. McGraw 4 guest appearances Mayor Sam Booth 4 guest appearances Harry Pierce 3 guest appearances Victoria Brandon Griffin 3 guest appearances Howard Griffin 3 guest appearances Donna Mayberry Fletcher 3 guest appearances Ted Hartley 3 guest appearances Phyllis Grant 3 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 » ⇥