Main Characters Penelope 'Penny' Barnes Barrington 29 main appearances Jake Silver 29 main appearances Dylan Messinger 29 main appearances Gavin Stone 24 main appearances Lucia Rojas-Klein Sister Brenda Trogman Claire Arnold Frank Jennifer Alfano
Recurring Guest Characters Frank Alfano 12 guest appearances Robby 12 guest appearances Lucia Rojas-Klein 10 guest appearances Sister Brenda Trogman 9 guest appearances Claire Arnold 8 guest appearances Joni 8 guest appearances Victoria Hill 8 guest appearances Camera Guy 5 guest appearances Roberta Diaz 3 guest appearances Carl 3 guest appearances Stacy 3 guest appearances Cindy 1 guest appearances Old Woman 1 guest appearances Dr. Seltzer 1 guest appearances Guy 1 guest appearances Dale the Delivery Guy 1 guest appearances Louise Messinger 1 guest appearances Nurse Debbie 1 guest appearances Water Guy 1 guest appearances Group Leader 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 » ⇥