Main Characters Penelope 'Penny' Barnes Barrington 29 main appearances Jake Silver 29 main appearances Dylan Messinger 29 main appearances Gavin Stone 24 main appearances Lucia Rojas-Klein Sister Brenda Trogman Claire Arnold Frank Jennifer Alfano
Recurring Guest Characters Ted Allen 1 guest appearances Kyan Douglas 1 guest appearances Thom Filicia 1 guest appearances Steve 1 guest appearances Carson Kressley 1 guest appearances Jai Rodriguez 1 guest appearances Trevor 1 guest appearances Hollis 1 guest appearances Jay 1 guest appearances Ty 1 guest appearances Elaine 1 guest appearances Woman 1 guest appearances Ken 1 guest appearances Man 1 guest appearances Donald 1 guest appearances Jimmy 1 guest appearances Trip 1 guest appearances Lila 1 guest appearances Dylan's Cookie Rejecter 1 guest appearances Phil 1 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 3 4 » ⇥