Guest Stars Scott Michael Foster as Nathaniel Plimpton III Michael McMillian as Tim Esther Povitsky as Maya Burl Moseley as Jim Kittsworth Rene Gube as Father Joseph / "Father Brah" Tovah Feldshuh as Naomi Bunch Parvesh Cheena as Sunil Odhav Paul Welsh as Trent Maddock David Grant Wright as Nathaniel Plimpton II John Allen Nelson as Silas Bunch Tanisha Long as Sara Seth Green as Patrick Co Starring Rob Humphreys as Drummer
