Guest Stars John Slattery as Michael Cassidy L. Scott Caldwell as Tanya Miller Caroline Aaron as Eloise Darline, Amy's Lawyer Michael Jace as Mr. Rhymers Cody Bischoff as Robby Lawler Kyle Bischoff as Robby Lawler Marlene Forté as Margaret Lopez Michael Bryan French as Mr. Reeves Brett Rickaby as Brian Lawler Roger Aaron Brown as Judge Fastbind Joe Mazza as Barry Burkman Natalie Beth Smith as Sally Lawler Eric Dyson as Cel Phone Guy Michele Hess as Juror Karen Piluso as Assistant D.A. Smith Orly Sitowitz as Paige Lawler Mike Weinberg as Ted Lawler Joshua Preven as Monroe Horwitz Jonathan Stockwell Baker as Roland Thompson Jessica Townsend as Ellen Reeves Marilyn McIntyre as Ellen's Mother
