Guest Stars Mimi Lieber as ASA Thelma Ryan Adam Brody as Barry 'Romeo' Gilmore Susan Ruttan as Lyla Myles Stephanie Nash as Mrs. Gilmore Jill Holden as Ann McNaughton Ken Abraham as Cop David Spielberg as Howard Erskine Gerald S. O'Loughlin as Mr. Sadler Mary Pat Dowhy as Marnie Stadler Katherine Brunk as Jenny Payne Amy Van Horne as Ms. Delillo Alan Gelfant as Art Vandalay Kyle Chambers as Brent Sadler