Guest Stars Timothy Omundson as Sean Potter Inny Clemons as Robert Clifton Richard Burgi as Michael Cassidy Chris Sarandon as Judge Barry Krumble James Patrick Stuart as Charles Manners Julia McIlvaine as Pamela Taylor Rachael Harris as Alumni Volunteer #2 Anton Yelchin voices Davis Bishop Sean Smith as Alumni Volunteer #1 Gretchen German as Elise Rolfston Robert Mailhouse as David Humboldt