Guest Stars Laura Benanti as USPIS Agent Edie Max Casella as Joe Delicious Mamoudou Athie as Carl Jeffrey Vincent Parise as Carlos Catrina Ganey as Judge Westlake John Scurti as Coach Co Starring Meredith Handerhan as Stenographer Fletcher Jones as Young Nate Nelson Cheng as Sam San Michelle Sohn as Sarah's Mom Tuffy Questell as Old Jared Gabby Alex Gutierrez as Sarah Sean Patrick Campbell as Opposing Player #1
