Guest Stars Jeffrey Pierce as Randall Reese Tom Verica as Ed Nielson Kim Staunton as Naomi Jones Susan Sullivan as Nancy Hale Jamie McShane as Henry Vartak Lillian Hurst as Consuela Hernandez Alex Fernandez as The Mayor Corey Stoll as Alex Kent Bertila Damas as Anna Rios John Pleshette as Mr. Kates JoBeth Williams as Sheryl Kates Sasha Alexander as Juliana Bill Smitrovich as Powell Steve Rankin as FBI Profiler Co Starring Michael Emanuel as Tom Mitchell Jasmine Villegas as Tiffany Andrew Lukich as Fed #2 Tracey Costello as Fed #3 Amy Koppelman as Cousin