Special Guest Stars Elizabeth Bogush as Alison Rowan Guest Stars Penny Johnson Jerald as Leslie Etwood James Keane as Sully Amy Acker as Jenny Bristol Armand Assante as Gabriel Diaz Bre Blair as Bethany Amanda Tepe as Jody Watson Claudia Mason as Vanessa Co Starring Christopher Eric Tschupp as Matthew Lauche Bryce Robinson as Connor Destiny Whitlock as Caitlin Jared Ward as Trent