Guest Stars Bill Heck as Ty Morstan Kristen Bush as Eileen Renfro Dallas Roberts as Dr. Richard Mantlo Ward Horton as Soap Opera Actor Annika Boras as Amy Damper Manny Perez as Detective Javier Abreu Jonathan Walker as Harrison Polk Co Starring Michael Nathanson as Infomercial Narrator Craig Walker as Peter Saldua Randal Turner as Male Opera Singer Melissa Zapin as Female Opera Singer Sherry H. Arell as Shushing Lady