Guest Stars Chris Bauer as Detective Gerry Coventry Troy Garity as Lucas Bundsch Eric Sheffer Stevens as Tim Spalding Co Starring Dee Pelletier as Polygraph Examiner Marcus Callender as Young Cop Howard W. Overshown as Detective Charlotte Maier as Cynthia Tilden Kate Cullen Roberts as Kathy Spalding Dillan Arrick as Jenna Lombard Ryan McCarthy as Sheriff's Officer #1 Lucas Dixon as Sheriff's Officer #2 Kacie Sheik as Receptionist