Guest Stars Ashley Crow as Sandra Bennet David H. Lawrence XVII as Eric Doyle Željko Ivanek as Emile Danko Dan Byrd as Luke Campbell Taylor Cole as Rachel Mills Justin Baldoni as Alex Woolsley Co Starring Randall Bentley as Lyle Bennet Jonny Siew as Analyst Jason E. Kelley as Agent #1 Jeff Campbell as Male Agent Joshua Rush as Little Sylar Frank Maharajh as Worker Angela Martinez as Andrea Charles Kelly Michaels as Guard Natalie Salins as Sylar's Mother Dan Shadwell as News Anchor