Guest Stars Jill Marie Jones as Cynthia Irving Sakina Jaffrey as Sheriff Leena Reyes Patrick Gorman as Reverend Knapp Michelle Trachtenberg as Abigail Adams Aaron Serotsky as Grant Hollister Co Starring Daniel Thomas May as James Colby Victor Cordova as Officer #1 Elise Duquette as Server Shaun Clay as Officer #2 Parisa Johnston as Docent Gregory Nassif St. John as Evan Miller