Guest Stars Beau Wirick as Sean Donahue Jen Ray as Nancy Donahue Alphonso McAuley as Hutch Daniela Bobadilla as Lexie Brooks Katlin Mastandrea as Ashley Galadriel Stineman as Cassidy Finch Gia Mantegna as Devin Levin Greer Grammer as April Keaton Savage as Tyler Co Starring Dierk Torsek as Reverend Hayver
