Guest Stars Rachelle Lefevre as Katie Campbell Tom Amandes as Don Branford Meredith Monroe as Molly Pierson Kate Burton as Mrs. Grace Graham Reggie Lee as Robert Timothy Omundson as Mr. Tim Ollerman Sarah Habel as Erin Conway Richard Gant as Judge Byron Cole Noa Tishby as Rachel Blau William Schallert as Mr. Hal Douglas Abigail Marlowe as Lisa Maxwell Huckabee as Will Pierson