Guest Stars David Giuntoli as Jason Carpenter Kelley Johnson as Francesca Joanne Kelly as Mia Smith Kevin Alejandro as Connor Smith Christina Chang as Ada Jan Yoshida Dana Wheeler-Nicholson as Judge Reyes Cherami Leigh as Sarah Brett Davern as Charlie Deneen Tyler as Dr. Coufal Kathryn Smith-McGlynn as Insurance Lawyer Brenda Isaacs-Booth as Mrs. Holloway Matthew Stephen Tompkins as Mr. Holloway