Special Guest Stars Brian Doyle-Murray as Robert Singer Guest Stars Sebastian Roché as Balthazar Micah Hauptman as Eric Kripke Genevieve Padalecki as Herself (Genevieve Cortese) Garwin Sanford as Jim Michaels Carlos Sanz as Virgil Jason Bryden as Kevin Parks Co Starring Lanette Ware as Raphael Hilary Jardine voices Sera Gamble Amitai Marmorstein as Gopher Reese Alexander as Gunstore Owner Emily Fonda as Makeup Girl #1 Lisa Marie Caruk as Trish Evion Ryan Beil as Set Guy Rick Dobran as Homeless Man Lou Bollo as Himself Art Kitching as Serge Ladouceur Phil Hayes as Clif Uncredited Arianne Zucker as Nicole Walker