Special Guest Stars Joan Cusack as Sheila Jackson Guest Stars Vanessa Bell Calloway as Carol Fisher Tyler Jacob Moore as Tony Markovich Joel Murray as Eddie Jackson Tim Bagley as Officer Mike Co Starring Missy Doty as Jess Virginia Morris as Mrs. Bergdoll Jes Macallan as Tammy Rebecca Hall as Newscaster Cheryl Texiera as Tina Billy Mayo as Dispatch William Smillie as Mr. Casden Tyler Anderson as Kenny Dombrowski Kate James as Bystander #2 Allison Latta as Mrs. Casden Ben Tedder as Bystander #1