Special Guest Stars Charisma Carpenter as Maggie Stark James Marsters as Donald Stark Guest Stars Sean Owen Roberts as Chet Co Starring Cindy Busby as Jenny Klein Nils Hognestad as Chris Alycia Purrott as Wendy Goodson Michael Patric as Sheriff Jason Bax as Dewey Stevens Tanya Hubbard as Wendy's Sister Meredith McGeachie as Sue