Guest Stars Andy Milder as Dean Hodes Indigo as Vaneeta Shoshannah Stern as Megan Graves Becky Thyre as Pam Tressa DiFiglia as Maggie Shawn Schepps as Alison Jane Lynch as The Candy Man Soledad St. Hilaire as Blanca Craig X. Rubin as Craig X David Pressman as Insurance Adjuster Joey Gray as Brian Jesse Head as Caleb Devon Gearhart as Billy Kathleen M. Darcy as Teacher Jina Song as Reporter