Guest Stars Mark Sheppard as Crowley Osric Chau as Kevin Tran Alaina Huffman as Josie Sands / Abaddon Ashton Holmes as Ephraim Tanya Clarke as Nora Co Starring Darla Fay as Lottery Customer Michael Kopsa as Sheriff Mary Galloway as Jace Chris Robson as Joe (Suicidal Man) Mackenzie Cardwell as Heartbroken Teenager Kalvin Olafson as Gas-N-Sip Coffee Customer James Melville as Bill David Braithwaite as Joe Conor Gomez as Gas-N-Sip Coffee Customer