Guest Stars Robert Knepper as Tommy Dolan John Carroll Lynch as Varlyn Stroud Blake Shields as Osgood Scott MacDonald as Burley K Callan as Eleanor McGill Daniel Browning Smith as Rubber Boy Eliza Pryor Nagel as Celeste Watkins Dennis W. Hall as Garrett Tracey Evans as Second Nun Tom Roberts as Migrant Worker Sarah Amstutz as Ada Olga Karavaeva as Carni Wife John Blevins as Cooch Patron Derrick O'Connor as Father Kerrigan Beth Tapper as Sister Agatha Saemi Nakamura as Hiroshi Price Carson as Prison Guard