Guest Stars Katie Finneran as Belle Rayburn Steven Pasquale as Alec Wolos Mia Kirshner as Sarah Rayburn Co Starring Taylor Rouviere as Janey Rayburn Brandon Larracuente as Ben Rayburn Michael Beasley as Little Jake Angela Winiewicz as Sarah Rayburn (10 Year Old) Randy Gonzalez as Manny The Bellman Jim R. Coleman as Fisherman Freddie Indigo as Gwen Girard Betsy Graver as Sheryl Carmela Zumbado as Pretty Girl #2 Christina Bach as Mrs. Weller Nevy Rey as Pretty Girl #1 George Morton as Old Man Erika Ender as Donna Hawksley Brendan Powers as Mr. Weller Uncredited Heather L. Porter as Bartender Robert J. Fox as Family Member Patrick H. Fox as Relative (Cousin) Tommy O'Brien as Bud Heathyre Perara as Bus Passenger