Guest Stars Wakeema Hollis as Monica Colby Brianna Brown as Claudia Blaisdel Nick Wechsler as Matthew Blaisdel Dave Maldonado as Willy Miller Co Starring Skylar Morgan Jones as Young Fallon Paul Luke Bonenfant as Young Steven Amelia Jeffries as Ida Jordan M. Cox as Ryan Devyn Ariel Tyler as Brianna Trayce Malachi as Village Kid Chelle Ramos as Libby Brandi Nicole as Desk Clerk Robert Pralgo as Prather Denitra Isler as Waitress Fiona Hardingham as Alice Daniel Norris as Thumper Driver Shawn Passwaters as Don Jr. Zack Arias as Photographer Suzanne Salhaney as Glynnis Morgan Roberts as Eric Craig S. Murphy as Minister