Guest Stars Curtis Armstrong as Metatron Tahmoh Penikett as Ezekiel / Gadreel Lindsey McKeon as Tessa Co Starring Erica Carroll as Hannah Enid-Raye Adams as Mother Malcolm Masters as Benjamin Kaaren de Zilva as Flagstaff Kevin O'Grady as Tyrus Farryn VanHumbeck as Esther Troy Mundle as Skeevy Man Owen Mason as Boy at Ice Cream Shop Max Kashetsky as Constantine Vaughn Jones as Josiah Jackie Blackmore as Sheriff Cardi Wong as Ice Cream Shop Patron RJ Fetherstonhaugh as Ice Creap Shop Employee Daniel McClelland as Oren Ryley Antoniuk as TBD