Special Guest Stars Rob Benedict as Chuck Shurley / God Guest Stars Alyssa Lynch as Siobhan Katie Sarife as Marie Joy Regullano as Maeve Co Starring Natalie Sharp as Maggie Hannah Levien as Calliope Kelli Ogmundson as Alice Vivien Elizabeth Armour as Katie Rachel Warkentin as Tammy Alberta Mayne as Mrs. Ellie Chandler Nina Winkler as Kristen Georgia Beaty as Yellow Eyed Demon Jannen Karr as Principal Salazar