Guest Stars Maggie Geha as Ivy Pepper Anthony Carrigan as Victor Zsasz Charlie Tahan as Jonathan Crane / Scarecrow Larry Pine as Mayor Burke Michael Maize as Grady Harris Damian Young as Warden Reed Michael Buscemi as Merton Co Starring Andrew Sellon as Mr. Penn / Mr. Scarface Joanne Nosuchinsky as Reporter Harry Sutton Jr. as Commissioner Scotty Crowe as Reporter #2 Garrett Richmond as Merton Gang #1 Terrence Shingler as GCPD Cop Antino Crowley-Kamenwati as Merton Gang #2 Ken Forman as Bank Manager Alberto Vázquez as Bodega Owner Decater James as Detective Mason Ken Wulf Clark as Crook Nicky Schmimdlein as Reporter #1 Leila Almas as Bride Joe Feldman-Barros as Groom Jim Ng as Dark Figure
